On Friday, August 16 the Hindu American Foundation sent the following letter to the New York City Mayor Eric Adams, expressing support for the inclusion of float commemorating the re-establish of a Ram Mandir in Ayodhya in the annual India Day Parade. The letter also criticizes the statements made by critics of the inclusion of float as omitting “important historical context, distorting the sacred site’s history in furtherance of their aims. They fail to mention the well-documented archaeological evidence and historical records showing the site’s continuous sacred use by Hindus and adherents of other Dharma traditions since the second millennia BCE. “
The full text of the letter is below:
August 16, 2024
Honorable Mayor Adams and Commissioner Caban,
We write to you on behalf of the Hindu American Foundation (HAF), the oldest and largest education and civil rights non-profit organization working to protect the dignity and rights of Hindu Americans.
We appreciate your office’s acknowledgment of its obligations under the U.S. and New York Constitutions to protect the rights to freedom of expression and assembly. While cities can regulate the time, place, and manner of parades through permit requirements, these regulations must be content-neutral, may not infringe upon constitutionally-protected expression, and must include procedural safeguards to avoid prior restraints. Decisions around permit requirements must also be based on objective criteria and not by the content of expression.
A small yet vocal group of organizations has demanded the removal of a float commemorating the re-opening of the Sri Rama temple from the Federation of Indian Association’s 40th Annual India Day parade, claiming it is Islamophobic. The Sri Rama temple is located at the birthplace of Sri Rama, who for thousands of years has been venerated by Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs as an embodiment of human goodness and manifestation of the Divine. Celebrating the birthplace of a revered deity is in no way an offense to any other religious community; to suggest otherwise is to insinuate that diverse cultures, faiths, and backgrounds cannot coexist in peace, which is the very foundation of our vibrant and secular nation.
Those demanding the float’s removal have conveniently omitted important historical context, distorting the sacred site’s history in furtherance of their aims. They fail to mention the well-documented archaeological evidence and historical records showing the site’s continuous sacred use by Hindus and adherents of other Dharma traditions since the second millennia BCE. In the 16th century, the Mughal Empire built a mosque atop the sacred site, calling it Masjid-e-Janmastan, which loosely translates to “mosque of the birthplace” in reference to Sri Rama’s birthplace. Later it was referred to as Babri Masjid, named for the Mughal Emperor who commissioned it.
The right to expression is intricately linked to the right to religious liberty. The Sri Rama temple float gives space to Sri Rama and his life’s story, the Ramayana. one of the most influential works of ancient India and beyond. Given the ill-intended attempts to steep a longstanding celebration of Indian Americans, Indian Independence, and Indian culture in controversy, we ask that extra measures be taken to secure not only the rights, but also the safety of those hosting and attending the festivities this weekend.
Thank you for your support in upholding constitutionally protected rights and ensuring another successful India Day Parade. If you have any questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to reach us at legal@hinduamerican.org
Sincerely,
Suhag A. Shukla, Esq., Executive Director | Co-Counsel
Samir Kalra, Esq. – Managing Director | Co-Counsel